TABLE OF CONTENTS
You think managing people is tough? Try doing it while everyone’s walking on eggshells, avoiding the hard conversations, and pretending everything’s fine when it’s clearly not.
Here’s the brutal truth: Most managers are absolute garbage at giving feedback. They are wweak as Ultra Light Beer but don’t know it. So they dance around issues, Avoid the problem not saying anything, sugarcoat problems, and wonder why their teams keep making the same damn mistakes over and over. Sound familiar? Good. Because today we’re going to fix that.
The Leader’s Cardinal Sin: Pointing Fingers Instead of Taking Ownership
Before you even think about having a performance conversation with your team, you need to get your head straight about one thing: Everything that happens on your team is ultimately your responsibility. Period. End of discussion.
That underperforming team member? That missed deadline? That project that went sideways? Stop pointing fingers and start looking in the mirror. Because here’s what elite leaders know that average managers don’t: When people don’t understand, they can’t execute. And if they don’t understand, that’s on YOU.
Instead of getting frustrated with others, examine what you could have done to fix the problem or prevent it from happening in the first place. Did your team actually understand the plan? Was it communicated in a simple, clear, and concise manner? Did you ask for a readback to ensure your communication was effective? “ Ok what did wee agree to here?” It is incredible how inaccurately or incompletely your team member or team heard you or translated expectations. That is T.R.O.U.B.L.E.
Taking ownership means diving into these challenges head-first and attacking the root of the problem, which starts with you. Simple concept. Not always easy to execute. But it separates the leaders who build legendary teams from those who just manage people.
The Three-Pillar Framework for Difficult Conversations
When it comes to having those tough performance conversations that most leaders avoid like the plague, you need a framework that actually works. Not some fluffy, feel-good approach that sounds nice in theory but falls apart under pressure.
Here’s the system that transforms good managers into great leaders:
Pillar 1: Say It With Control
Before you open your mouth, you better have control of yourself. Your emotions, your body language, your tone – everything. Because the moment you lose control, you’ve lost the conversation.
Start with your breathing. Deep, controlled breaths activate your parasympathetic nervous system and keep you centered when the conversation gets heated. Your team member might be defensive, angry, or completely shut down. But you? You stay in control. Do Not! Ever go at a situation when your emotions are elevated. You are screwing yourself and your leadership and trust the team has for you. They won’t tell you, they will accept your aplolgy, if you give one, but you screwed yourself and that damage lasts a long time.
That’s where the 24 Hour Rule comes in. Exceptions to this? Sure, but the rule is, always wait to the next day to address a situation that has you pissed off or embarrassed. You will have calmed the hell down and will have had time to formulate a conversation that will but smart, to the point and effective.
Control also means choosing your words deliberately. No emotional outbursts. No passive-aggressive comments. No sarcasm designed to cut deep. You speak with intention, purpose, and clarity.
Pillar 2: Say It With Confidence
Confidence doesn’t mean being an arrogant ass. It means being clear, direct, and unwavering in your standards while remaining respectful.
Use phrases like:
- “I need you to understand that…”
- “Here’s what I’m seeing…”
- “This is what needs to change…”
- “I believe you’re capable of better…”
Notice how these phrases own the conversation without attacking the person? That’s confidence in action. You’re not hedging, you’re not apologizing for having standards, and you’re not beating around the bush.
Confidence is about setting clear expectations without ambiguity. When you speak with confidence, people listen. When you speak with uncertainty, people tune out.
Pillar 3: Say It to Connect
Here’s where most managers completely screw up. They think feedback is about telling people what they did wrong and expecting them to magically fix it. Or worse you telling them how to fix it. Wrong approach. Have a dialog with them coming up with the solution, not you. People are much more likely to follow through with what they said they will do verses what they are told to do.
Connection means you’re having this conversation because you care about their growth and success. You’re not trying to embarrass them or assert your authority. You’re trying to help them win.
Start by acknowledging their strengths. Then address the performance issue as something you’re going to solve together. Use language like:
- “I see your potential, and that’s why we need to address this…”
- “I want to help you succeed, and here’s what’s getting in the way…”
- “You’re valuable to this team, and I need you to step up in this area…”
When people know you’re on their side, they stop being defensive and start being collaborative.
Setting Crystal Clear Expectations: The Foundation of Everything
Here’s what separates elite leaders from the rest: They set expectations so clear that there’s zero room for interpretation.
Most managers say things like “do better” or “improve your performance” and wonder why nothing changes. That’s not setting expectations – that’s hoping for magic.
Elite leaders say things like:
- “I need you to respond to client emails within 4 hours during business days”
- “Your reports need to include X, Y, and Z data points and be submitted by 2 PM every Friday”
- “In team meetings, I expect you to speak up with at least one question or contribution”
See the difference? Specific. Measurable. Actionable. Your are now on the same page.
When you set vague expectations, you get vague results. When you set clear expectations, you get clear accountability.
The Performance Feedback Formula That Actually Works
Ready for the secret sauce? Here’s how you structure a performance feedback conversation that gets results:
Step 1: Establish the Purpose “I want to talk with you about [specific behavior/performance issue] because I know you’re capable of more.”
Step 2: Present the Facts “Here’s what I’m observing…” (Be specific, objective, not personal)
Step 3: Explore Root Causes Together “Help me understand what’s happening from your perspective.”
Step 4: Collaborate on Solutions “What do you think would help you improve in this area?”
Step 5: Set Clear Next Steps “Here’s what I need from you going forward… and here’s how I’ll support you.”
Step 6: Follow Up “Let’s check in on this in two weeks to see how things are going.”
Notice what’s happening here? You’re not lecturing them. You’re not attacking them. You’re solving the problem together while maintaining clear ownership of the outcome.
The Performance Feedback Conversation That Actually Works: A Story
Setting: Sarah’s office, 2 PM on a Tuesday. Sarah (the manager) has been avoiding this conversation for three weeks. Mike (senior developer) thinks he’s crushing it. Reality? His code reviews are taking forever and the team’s getting restless.
Sarah: (Takes a deep breath, centers herself) Mike, thanks for making time. I want to talk with you about your code review process because I know you’re capable of more than what I’m seeing right now.
Mike: (Immediately defensive) What do you mean? I’m being thorough. That’s good, right?
Sarah: (Stays calm, doesn’t take the bait) Here’s what I’m observing. Over the past three weeks, your code reviews are averaging 4-5 days turnaround. The rest of the team is averaging 24-48 hours. Yesterday, Jenny’s pull request sat in your queue for six days, which blocked her from starting the next feature.
Mike: (Shifting in his seat) Look, I’m just trying to catch every bug before—
Sarah: (Interrupts gently but firmly) Hold up. I’m not questioning your attention to detail. That’s actually one of your strengths. Help me understand what’s happening from your perspective. What’s making these reviews take so long?
Mike: (Pauses, thinking) Well… honestly? I feel like if I miss something and it breaks production, it’s on me. So I go through everything with a fine-tooth comb. Sometimes I rewrite sections entirely before approving.
Sarah: (Leaning forward) Ah, now we’re getting somewhere. I get it – you want to protect the codebase. That’s exactly why you’re valuable to this team. But here’s the thing: your thoroughness is becoming a bottleneck that’s frustrating your teammates and slowing down our sprint goals.
Mike: (Defensive walls coming down) I didn’t realize it was affecting everyone else.
Sarah: What do you think would help you maintain your quality standards while moving faster through reviews?
Mike: (Thinking out loud) Maybe… I could focus on bigger issues first? And instead of rewriting code myself, I could just flag it and explain what needs to change?
Sarah: (Nodding) Exactly! And here’s another thought – what if we set up a quick 15-minute daily check-in where you can bounce questions off me? That way you’re not second-guessing yourself on every small decision.
Mike: That would actually help a lot. Sometimes I spend an hour debating whether something’s worth flagging.
Sarah: Perfect. So here’s what I need from you going forward: Code reviews completed within 48 hours max. Focus on functionality, security, and major style issues – leave the nitpicky stuff for later iterations. And here’s how I’ll support you: daily check-ins for the next two weeks, and I’ll make sure you have clear guidelines on what constitutes “review-worthy” versus “ship-it-and-improve-later.”
Mike: (Actually looking relieved) That sounds reasonable. And honestly? Thanks for not just telling me to “be faster.” I needed to understand the why.
Sarah: Let’s check in on this next Tuesday. I want to see how the new process feels and if we need to adjust anything. Sound good?
Mike: Yeah, absolutely. And Sarah? I appreciate you having this conversation instead of just… you know, letting it fester.
Sarah: (Standing up, extending hand for shake) That’s what good leaders do, Mike. We tackle problems head-on because we give a damn about our people.
What just happened here? Pure damn magic, that’s what.
Notice how Sarah didn’t attack Mike’s character or make him feel like shit? She identified the specific behavior, explored the root cause together, and created a solution that honored his strengths while addressing the team’s needs.
Mike walked out of that office feeling supported, not destroyed. He understood exactly what needed to change and had a clear path forward.
That’s how you handle performance feedback like a boss.
Building a Culture of Extreme Ownership
Performance management isn’t just about solving individual problems. It’s about building a culture where everyone takes ownership, relationships are built on trust, and teams continuously innovate and adapt.
When team members see that you take ownership, address challenges effectively, and show that you care about their growth, they’re more likely to do the same. It becomes contagious.
Think about it: When was the last time someone on your team came to you with a problem they’d already started solving? When did someone last admit they made a mistake before you had to point it out? That’s what ownership culture looks like.
The Weekly Challenge That Changes Everything
Here’s your homework, leader. This week, evaluate one area where your team is underperforming. Just one. Don’t try to fix everything at once.
Identify the root cause. Take ownership of the problem. Implement a solution using the framework we just covered.
Ask yourself these tough questions:
- Did I communicate clearly enough?
- Did I set proper expectations?
- Did I provide adequate resources and support?
- Did I follow up consistently?
Get my Free Tool “The 16 Reasons Employees Don’t Do What They Are Supposed To”
Remember: The best way to get others to take ownership is for you to take ownership first.
The Bottom Line
Great leaders don’t avoid difficult conversations – they master them. They don’t hope problems will fix themselves – they address them head-on with clarity, confidence, and genuine care for their people.
Your team is watching how you handle these moments. They’re deciding whether you’re the type of leader worth following into battle or just another manager they need to work around.
The choice is yours. You can keep dancing around issues, hoping things improve, watching your best people get frustrated and leave. Or you can step up, take ownership, and have the conversations that actually matter.
Stop making excuses. Start making changes. Your team – and your career – depend on it.
Because here’s the reality: In a world where everyone’s trying to avoid conflict, the leader who can navigate difficult conversations with skill and confidence doesn’t just survive – they dominate.
You Need This Course
Time to get to after it!
Related Posts
If you enjoyed reading this, then please explore our other articles below:
