Discover the Startling Truth about Accidental Managers

In today’s business environment, which is getting more difficult every day, effective leadership is more crucial than ever. However, a troubling trend has emerged, with a large number of managers finding themselves in leadership positions without the necessary training or qualifications. These “accidental managers” may mean well, but their lack of expertise can have serious consequences for their teams and the companies they work for.

Shocking Statistics That Demand Attention

A recent survey conducted by the Chartered Management Institute (CMI) has revealed some alarming statistics about the state of management and leadership.

  • A staggering 82% of those who become managers have little to no training or qualification, even though one in four people in the workforce takes on management responsibilities.
  • Over half of the managers surveyed admitted to having no management or leadership qualifications.
  • Even more concerning, 26% of senior managers and leaders also fall into this category.

The Root Cause of the Problem

Leader vs manager is shown using the text and pictures of difference between chiefs.

Mastering the Crucial Transition: Becoming an Effective Manager

Becoming a manager is more than just a promotion – it’s a profound shift in responsibilities and skillsets. While someone may excel in their field or area of expertise, successfully managing and leading a team demands an entirely different set of abilities. Relying on the assumption that a high-performing employee will automatically become an effective manager is not only flawed, but it can also be detrimental to an organization’s well-being.

Many companies mistakenly believe that leadership and management skills are innate qualities that will naturally emerge once someone is given a managerial title. This mindset contributes significantly to the challenges faced in today’s workplaces. Without proper training and guidance, new managers are left to navigate the complexities of leadership on their own, often resulting in inefficiencies, decreased team morale, and even employee turnover.

Additionally, the lack of a clear career roadmap that includes management and leadership training is a significant oversight in many organizations. Ideally, potential leaders should undergo this training before they are promoted. If that’s not possible, it should be an essential part of their development plan during their first year as a manager. This approach not only equips them with the necessary skills but it also establishes clear expectations and standards for leadership within the company.

Furthermore, the common practice of hiring external managers based solely on “experience” is riddled with pitfalls. Experience does not always guarantee effectiveness. If a manager has progressed through various roles without proper leadership training, they are likely to bring the same inefficiencies and knowledge gaps into their new position. By hiring such individuals, companies inadvertently import the problems of other organizations into their own. This perpetuates the widespread issue of underprepared managers leading teams – a mistake seen countless times across the business world every day.

Here are common examples of how the ineffective accidental manager is created.

Promotion Based on Technical Skills Alone: Often, top-performing employees in non-managerial roles are promoted to leadership positions based on their technical prowess or domain expertise. However, managerial roles require a different skill set, including people management, strategic thinking, and decision-making.

Lack of Training: Many organizations do not provide adequate training for new managers. Without proper guidance, these managers are left to figure things out on their own, leading to mistakes and inefficiencies.

Rapid Growth: In fast-growing companies, there’s a pressing need to fill managerial roles quickly. This can lead to promoting individuals without giving much thought to their managerial capabilities or providing them with the necessary support.

Cultural Factors: In some organizational cultures, there’s an implicit belief that anyone can manage if given the opportunity. This overlooks the specialized skills and temperament required for effective management.

Lack of Succession Planning: Companies without a clear succession plan might find themselves in a position where they need to fill a managerial role unexpectedly. In such cases, they might promote someone without evaluating if they are truly ready for the role.

Fear of External Hiring: Some companies prefer to promote from within, even if it means placing an unprepared individual in a managerial role, rather than hiring an external candidate with more experience.

Misunderstanding the Role: There’s a misconception that management is a natural progression in one’s career. Both employees and employers might see it as the next logical step without considering whether the individual truly has an aptitude or desire for management.

Lack of Feedback Mechanisms: Without regular feedback from peers and subordinates, accidental managers might remain unaware of their shortcomings, perpetuating ineffective management practices.

The Damaging Effects of Poor Management

Shot of a young businessman looking stressed out in an office.

Having untrained managers in leadership positions has far-reaching consequences: Gallup, a global analytics and advice firm, has conducted extensive research on the state of the workplace and the role of managers and leaders. Their findings underscore the profound impact that leadership has on employee engagement, productivity, and overall company performance. Here are some impactful statistics from Gallup that highlight the negative effects of poorly trained leaders on today’s workforce:

Employee Engagement: According to Gallup, managers account for at least 70% of the variance in employee engagement scores across business units. This statistic underscores the pivotal role managers play in influencing how engaged their teams are. Poorly trained leaders can significantly dampen engagement, leading to decreased productivity and higher turnover.

Managerial Talent: Gallup’s research indicates that only one in ten people possess the natural talent to manage. This suggests that the vast majority of managers may need significant training and development to lead effectively. Without this, they might struggle to motivate their teams, resolve conflicts, or drive performance.

Promotion Decisions: Gallup found that companies fail to choose the candidate with the right managerial talent for a managerial position 82% of the time. This high percentage indicates that many organizations are not adequately evaluating leadership potential when making promotion decisions, leading to a prevalence of ill-equipped managers. A Gallup study discovered that only 1 in 10 people possess the necessary qualities to be a successful leader.

Employee Turnover: One of Gallup’s most telling findings is that one in two employees have left a job to get away from a manager and improve their overall life at some point in their career. This statistic underscores the profound impact that managers have on employee retention and satisfaction.

Low Turnover is Not Always a Good Sign: When underperforming employees stick around, it brings down morale and productivity. High-performing members get demotivated, and everyone’s engagement decreases. Research, including studies from Gallup, shows that having low-performing colleagues can seriously hurt a team’s engagement and productivity. And here’s the thing: talented employees don’t usually leave companies; they leave bad leaders. This loss of top talent only makes the problem worse, dragging down team performance and unity. It’s time to address the leadership issue and boost your team’s success.

Economic Impact: Gallup estimates that actively disengaged employees, often a result of poor management, cost the U.S. between $483 billion to $605 billion each year in lost productivity. This staggering figure highlights the economic implications of not investing in effective leadership training.

These statistics emphasize the critical importance of training and developing leaders. Companies that overlook the need for robust managerial training programs risk decreased employee engagement, higher turnover, and significant economic losses.

A Cautionary Tale: The Downfall of an Accidental Manager

Let’s take a closer look at the story of Jane, a top-performing employee at a tech company. Recognized for her hard work and dedication, she was rapidly promoted to a managerial position. However, Jane had no prior management training or experience.

In her new role, Jane struggled with delegation and often micromanaged her team. She lacked the emotional intelligence to handle conflicts, resulting in a tense work environment. Her dependence on personal relationships rather than data-driven insights led to poor decision-making.

As time went on, the team’s productivity declined, and talented employees started leaving due to the toxic environment Jane unintentionally created. The company also missed out on significant business opportunities because of her indecisiveness and lack of strategic vision.

Charting a Path Forward

It cannot be underestimated that the importance of emotional intelligence trumps IQ for managers. Managers don’t need to have all the answers; instead, their role is to create an environment where others can thrive and collaboratively find the answers.

While accidental managers may have good intentions, their lack of training can harm their teams and companies. It is crucial for organizations to recognize this gap and invest in proper training and development for their leaders.

Is Your Manager Out of Their Element? Signs to Watch For

Do you suspect that your manager might be struggling to lead their team effectively? Here are some key indicators to look out for:

Micromanagement: Is your manager constantly nitpicking and controlling every detail, hindering creativity and autonomy? Do they often blame team shortcomings on the team not being good enough or that it is hard to find good people? Do they complain about how many additional hours they have to work to get the job done? Sometimes, that hardworking manager is an ineffective manager.

Poor Communication: Does your manager struggle to convey expectations or provide constructive feedback clearly? Do they miss deadlines? Do they miss goals? Do they blame poor training on the team’s shortcomings? Do they have a lot of meetings? Do they claim that their team just has a hard time “understanding” simple instructions?

Avoidance of Conflict: Instead of addressing issues head-on, does your manager dodge confrontations, allowing problems to escalate? Do they procrastinate dealing with poor performance? Do they express optimism that a team member will improve because the manager is “working on them,” but the team member never really improves?

Inability to Delegate: Does your manager take on too much work themselves, leading to burnout and neglecting their managerial responsibilities? Again, that person you respect because of the long hours they are working is a strong signal that they are working hard and not smart. They are too involved in the day-to-day and spend little time on developing their team members because “they don’t have time.”

Lack of Vision: Is your manager unable to set or communicate a clear direction for the team? Do you scratch your head sometimes and think, “What were they thinking?” “Where did that come from?” or do you find them prioritizing duties that are not relevant to the mission? They waste time on low-level items and don’t devote enough effort or priority to the high-level of importance items.

Reliance on Favoritism: Do decisions seem to be based on personal relationships rather than merit or performance? Do they have a “superstar” that just does not seem to be all that great? Do they protect some of their team members from criticism and focus on others who seem to always be the culprit? Do they have outside relationships with team members?

Inconsistent Decision-Making: Does your manager frequently change their mind, causing confusion and mistrust among the team? Do they lose track of action plans? Do they fail at following through with key tasks? Do they fail to follow through with commitments often? Do they choose to spend time on the low level priorities?

If you’re noticing any of these signs, it’s important to act before the damage becomes widespread:

High Employee Turnover: If valuable employees are leaving due to poor management, it’s time to address the issue. If you see great people hired that often last a short period of time be concerned. Great people leave poor leaders. There are no bad teams. Only weak leaders.

Decreased Productivity: If teams led by untrained managers are consistently failing to meet their targets, intervention is necessary.

Low Morale: A disengaged team or lack of enthusiasm can be a clear indication of ineffective leadership.

Increased Complaints: A rise in grievances or conflicts can signal underlying managerial problems. Or, there is constant gossip with a group of employees?

Lack of Innovation: If teams feel held back or stifled by their managers, new ideas and creativity may suffer. Teams that are led by weak managers often struggle with adapting to change and create a lot of passive-aggressive push back to new approaches or initiatives.

Transforming Accidental Managers into Effective Leaders

While accidental managers may be common, their impact can be minimized through the right tools and training. By recognizing the signs of ineffective management and investing in feedback systems and training, organizations can transform these managers into effective leaders, driving success for their teams and the company as a whole.

  • Communication Workshops: To improve clarity and effectiveness in conveying messages.
  • Time Management Courses: To help managers allocate their time more efficiently.
  • Leadership Development Training: To improve their leadership skills and knowledge, they must be given a resource that will provide them with the tools and in a manner that will ensure retention of the knowledge with the proper application.
  • Self-Awareness: Unlocking the Potential of Effective Leadership with 360 Feedback

In the world of management and leadership, self-awareness is the key to success. It may seem like a simple concept, but many managers fail to acknowledge the importance of recognizing and addressing their own challenges. This is particularly true for those who struggle in their leadership roles.

Acknowledging the Challenge
The first step towards overcoming any challenge is admitting that it exists. This may sound like common sense, but it can be incredibly difficult, especially for experienced managers who are set in their ways. Without direct feedback, it’s easy to assume that everything is going well. However, this can lead to the development of bad habits that are difficult to break.

The Value of Honest Feedback
To get a true understanding of their leadership challenges, managers need honest feedback from their team members and peers. Unfortunately, direct reports and peers often sugarcoat their feedback or hold back due to fear of repercussions. This means that managers may not be getting an accurate view of their performance, which only reinforces their denial.

Harnessing the Power of 360 Feedback
This is where the 360-feedback program comes in. Providing a platform for anonymous feedback from direct reports, peers, and supervisors creates an environment where honesty is encouraged. Managers are finally able to receive unfiltered feedback that can serve as a wake-up call. This candid feedback from multiple sources forces managers to confront their challenges head-on.

The Path to Growth
Regular feedback is crucial for personal development. The sooner and more frequently managers receive feedback, the better equipped they are to make the necessary changes and seek out training or mentorship. By embracing the insights gained from the 360-feedback program, managers can become more effective leaders and foster a positive work environment.

For managers to excel in their roles, they must be willing to recognize and address their challenges. A 360-feedback program provides the honest, anonymous feedback needed to uncover strengths and weaknesses. By leveraging this feedback and taking proactive steps toward improvement, managers can become exceptional leaders and create a productive workplace.

An effective way to identify and address managerial shortcomings is through a 360-feedback system. This anonymous system allows for feedback from peers, subordinates, and superiors, painting a comprehensive picture of a manager’s performance.

Here are some examples of what 360 feedback might reveal:

  • Lack of Empathy: Feedback may indicate that the manager struggles to understand or consider the feelings of their team.
  • Ineffective Communication: Team members may feel they’re not receiving clear instructions or feedback.
  • Unavailability: The manager may not be providing enough time or support to their team.
  • Bias in Decision Making: There may be signs of favoritism or unfair treatment.


We’ve simplified the formula for leadership development.

Every leader is different and requires a unique approach to his or her development. The Talassure360 survey system uses anonymous feedback from colleagues to provide a uniquely personal experience. By requesting honest responses from coworkers about a leader’s performance in each area, you can visually overlap the various perceptions of performance, compare them against each other, and create an actionable plan of improvement for the future.

Use the Results Driven Leadership’s Talassure360 to manage the development of your leaders actively. Its effortless simplicity doesn’t sacrifice the quality of information or usability, providing understandable data of the highest integrity. Enhancing tomorrow’s leaders through today’s efforts.

Create a development plan: Talassure360 provides leaders with feedback from peers, team members, and superiors alike. Compiling and analyzing responses provides the clarity to develop a definitive path of continuous improvement.

Receive honest feedback: When Peers and Direct Reports respond to a Talassure360 survey, they do so completely anonymously. In this way, you can be assured that the results will not be colored by fear of repercussion or hopes of reward.

Foster self-awareness: By comparing a leader’s self-perception with the perceptions of their coworkers, Talassure360 can highlight gaps to create a better awareness of the leader’s response to the needs of their colleagues. When perceptions between peers, bosses and the leader align, there is a clear picture of already existing strengths to build upon.

It’s no secret that the higher the quality of your leadership team, the more productive and profitable your business will be. Invest in your business by providing your leaders with a launching pad for improvement.


  • Mobile Friendly Design
  • Engineered specifically for today’s mobile workforce

User-Friendly Reporting

  • Reports are clear and easily understandable.

Avoids Information Overload

  • Our results focus on the most impactful performance statistics.


  • Improved Leadership Team
  • More Engagement
  • Higher Productivity
  • Boosted Morale
  • Stronger Teamwork
  • Better Communication
  • Increased Accountability

Find out more about our Tallasure360 program.

Contact Us Here For More Information and a Free Consultation